Best Pacifiers for Premature Babies: What the NICU Uses and Why (2026)

This post contains affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure.

The first time a NICU nurse offered our son a pacifier, I remember thinking it seemed too soon — he was still being fed through a tube. Then she explained: for a preemie, sucking on a pacifier isn't just comfort. It's practice. Non-nutritive sucking is how premature babies build the suck-swallow-breathe coordination they'll need before they can ever take a bottle or breastfeed.

So the pacifier aisle matters more for preemie parents than for most — and it's also more confusing, because standard newborn pacifiers are frequently too big for a preemie's mouth. Here's what NICUs actually use, what's worth buying for home, and the safety rules that come with each.

What Pacifier Does the NICU Use?

In most American NICUs the default is the Philips Avent Soothie — the one-piece green silicone pacifier you have probably already seen in your baby's isolette. Hospitals use it because it is a single moulded piece with nothing to come apart, it sterilises easily, and the shape is the one most lactation consultants consider least likely to interfere with latching. If your unit gave you one, you can buy exactly the same pacifier retail.

For the smallest babies a Soothie is often still too big. Units that stock a true preemie size use one sized by gestational age rather than by month, and some use a scaled-down version of the same Soothie shape. Ask your nurse which one your baby is actually on before you buy anything — it is a thirty-second question at the cot side, and it saves you buying a shape your baby has already turned down.

Why pacifiers are different for preemies

• Size: a preemie's mouth is smaller, and an oversized nipple can trigger gagging instead of soothing. Preemie-specific pacifiers are sized by gestational age.
• Feeding development: non-nutritive sucking during tube feeds helps babies associate sucking with a full stomach — a stepping stone toward oral feeding.
• Comfort during procedures: NICUs routinely offer a pacifier (sometimes with a drop of sucrose) during heel sticks and IV placements — it measurably reduces pain response.
• Safe sleep: once feeding is established, offering a pacifier at sleep time is associated with a lower risk of SIDS — part of the AAP's safe sleep guidance.

And if you're worried a pacifier will sabotage breastfeeding: the research on preterm babies is reassuring. Reviews of the evidence have found pacifier use in premature infants doesn't appear to harm later breastfeeding — in the NICU context, the sucking practice tends to help oral feeding overall. Your lactation consultant can help you time it.

Philips Avent Soothie: the green one every NICU has

If your baby spent time in a US hospital, you've probably already met the Soothie — the translucent green pacifier handed out in maternity wards and NICUs across the country. It's molded as a single piece of hospital-grade, BPA- and latex-free silicone, which means no joints or cracks for milk and germs to hide in, and nothing that can separate. There's a dedicated NICU version with a notched shield that makes room for CPAP tubing or a feeding tube — that one is typically provided by the hospital, sized for babies from around 34 weeks.

Worth knowing: for the very smallest babies, Philips also makes the Wee Thumbie — a tiny pacifier modeled on a preemie's thumb, designed for very low birth weight babies before about 30 weeks. It's a hospital item rather than something to order online, so if your baby is that small, ask your NICU what they stock.

Ryan & Rose Cutie Preemie Kit: sized by gestational age

Ryan & Rose makes one of the few pacifier lines actually engineered around prematurity. The Cutie Preemie Kit comes with two sizes — a Tiny for babies under about 35 weeks and a Stage 1 for after — both in 100% medical-grade silicone, with a notched shield designed to coexist with CPAP, ET, and feeding tubes. If your baby is doing a long NICU stay and graduating between sizes, this is the thoughtful pick.

WubbaNub: the one with the animal attached — and its safety rule

You'll see WubbaNubs — a Soothie-style nipple with a small plush animal attached — all over NICUs, because the plush gives the pacifier enough weight and bulk to stay put near a baby who can't yet hold anything. Nurses love them for awake, monitored time.

The safety rule that comes with the cuteness: a pacifier with anything attached — plush, clip, or cord — is for supervised awake time only, never for sleep. At home, the WubbaNub is a daytime soother; the plain Soothie is the one that goes in the crib. (In the NICU your baby is continuously monitored, which is why you'll see them in isolettes — home is a different setting.)

Pacifier ground rules for preemies

• Follow your NICU's lead on timing — if your baby is still working on oral feeding, the care team will tell you when and how to offer one
• Choose one-piece construction and check regularly for tears or stickiness — replace at the first sign of wear
• Never tie a pacifier around your baby's neck or to the crib, and never dip it in anything sweet
• Don't force it — some babies take a pacifier instantly, some never do, and both are fine
• Size up using corrected age and your pediatrician's guidance, not the age printed on the package

Where this fits in the bigger feeding picture

Non-nutritive sucking is step one on the road from tube feeds to full oral feeding — we walk through that whole journey in our preemie feeding guide. And when your baby is ready for bottles, nipple flow rate becomes the thing to obsess over — that's covered in our guide to the best bottles for premature babies.

A pacifier was the first thing that made our son look like every other baby — just a kid, content, working on something. Small thing, big moment. From one preemie parent to another: it's okay to enjoy it.

As an Amazon Associate, Adjusted Age earns from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.